Who's Who in GATE:
IN-DEPTH WITH THE SCIENTISTS



I have asked Dr. Joanne Simpson, Dr. Peggy LeMone, Dr. Michio Yanai, and Dr. Bruce Albrecht about their experiences in GATE, what they personally got out of the experience, and how GATE has helped them in their careers. Each of these scientists has since been a primary organizer in another research project. I asked each scientist how GATE helped them with their more recent endeavors. In order to understand this report better, here is a brief synopsis of their research projects, followed by their responses to my questions.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

RESEARCH PROJECTS THAT THEY ARE CURRENTLY WORKING ON OR HAVE RECENTLY COMPLETED

OVERALL IMPRESSIONS OF GATE

WHAT DID YOU GET OUT OF GATE?

PERSONAL EXPERIENCES

HOW HAS GATE BEEN USEFUL IN THE REST OF YOUR CAREER?

OVERALL CONCLUSIONS (BY ANNELIESE SHERER)



RESEARCH PROJECTS THAT THEY ARE CURRENTLY WORKING ON OR HAVE RECENTLY COMPLETED

Simpson:

  Dr. Simpson's project is TRMM, the Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission. "Over two-thirds of worldwide precipitation falls in the tropics, releasing the energy that helps to power the global atmospheric circulation" (NASA). While tropical rainfall is an important aspect in determining the weather, it is extremely difficult to measure this rain since surface observations are not possible over the ocean. This mission is trying to measure tropical rainfall by satellite. This information is extremely important, as it will help scientists better understand El Nino-Southern Oscillation (ENSO), storms, monsoons, and droughts. In GATE, the data scientists collected confirmed that tropical rainfall "displays strong diurnal variations, with different phase structure over land and ocean and over different ocean regions. These findings imply that any satellite dedicated to tropical rainfall measurements should be placed in a non-polar orbit, in order to provide observations at all local times" (NASA). TRMM is a joint project between the United States and Japan. The Japanese "built the rain radar and provided the launch. The spacecraft was built here at Goddard" (Simpson, 1998). Dr. Simpson was asked in 1986 if she would be the Study Scientist for TRMM and she has stayed with the project ever since. The satellite was finally launched in 1997 and is now sending back images that scientists can study global warming, cyclones, climate change, and many other aspects of weather.

LeMone:
plane
Dr. LeMone's latest research project was CASES-97, which she coordinated with Bob Grossman. The boundary layer is the region closest to the ground (the lowest few thousand feet). While researchers understand how the boundary layer and the ground interact with one another, they do not have mathematical equations based on these interactions that can be used in forecasting. Certain variables, such as heating and evaporation rates at the surface and the mixing rate between lower and upper air in the boundary layer, must be measured in order to come up with mathematical equations. This project took place from April 22 to May 22 in the Walnut River watershed, which is east of Wichita, Kansas. Two airplanes, the University of Wyoming's King Air and the NOAA Twin Otter (a twin otter is seen in the picture above), were used to take measurements over the test area.

   Yanai:

Dr. Yanai is currently involved with the Tropical Meteorology Project at UCLA.  This project is researching different tropical motion systems and their interactions by using the data taken during different field experiments, including GATE.  This study took place in June 1992 off the North Africa coast, where the Azores and Madeira Islands are located.


 Albrecht:
One of Dr. Albrecht's most recent studies was ASTEX.  This experiment was designed to study large-scale clouds and how they are affected by aerosols, cloud microphysics, and chemistry.



OVERALL IMPRESSIONS OF GATE

"After the fact, I now think that GATE was the best field program of my lifetime and the most productive of significant publications. Participation in the Field Phase of the program was exciting and those of us doing it learned an enormous amount as well as making friends of colleagues from all over the world" (Simpson).

"I believe that the GATE data set is probably the most useful data set in tropical meteorology" (Simpson).

"I suspect now that the GATE area is one of the most cloudy oceanic areas in the global tropics" (Simpson).

"The oceanic boundary layer in GATE was a great laboratory--we probably had more data to characterize the fair weather boundary layer than most experiments before or since--we once documented flux profiles with three gust-probe aircraft--something I don't think has been repeated" (LeMone).

"GATE provided not only the excellent data but also a forum to exchange ideas for scientists working on many different aspects of meteorology. I think meteorologists of my generation profited greatly from the experience (in many different ways) in GATE" (Yanai).

"GATE provided me with an appreciation of the role of observations as a reality check for my modeling work" (Albrecht).


WHAT DID YOU GET OUT OF GATE?

Simpson:

Convective clouds produce significant amounts of anvil and stratiform precipitation. In GATE the amount of stratiform precipitation was comparable to the convective precipitation. Bob Houze was the person whose papers first made this an important recognized feature of tropical convective systems.

There are two main types of cloud systems, namely 1) slow moving cloud clusters and 2) fast moving arc-shaped squall lines. These latter are oriented approximately normal to the wind shear and can move faster than the strongest wind, which has a low-level jet structure when they occur. Ed Zipser's publications probably did the most to explain the structure and motion of GATE squall lines. There were several other strange cloud patterns mapped in GATE that may represent two features that have collided. (Unfortunately all the GATE data have not been worked up and published).

The downdrafts associated with GATE cloud clusters brought down into the lower boundary layer midlevel air which was cooler and drier than that of the undisturbed subcloud layer, thus shutting off convection for 4 to 8 hours and sometimes longer. These "wakes" of convection were first studied and reported, I believe, by Mike Garstang.
 

By the mid-1970's there were a number of sophisticated single-cloud models. The three-dimensional models had been designed for understanding mesocyclones and the formation of tornadoes. There were also two-dimensional models that could be used for weather modification studies. However, GATE clouds could not be easily simulated by 2-D models. Gary Van Helvoirt, a graduate student of Dr. Simpson's at the University of Virginia, used Dr. Schlesinger's Midwest cloud model and applied it to the GATE data. He examined how well this model worked on the GATE data. "...the model worked amazingly well and simulated the GATE clouds using the nearest GATE sounding without any tinkering or adjustment. The model worked equally well on some more modest sized GATE clouds and revealed some very interesting insights into the entrainment process which had been murky for nearly three decades."

From this same model (Gary Van Helvoirt's), it was discovered that "the motions inside the cloud were vortical (vorticity about the vertical axis)." When the researchers went back to the mesocyclone models from which this model came, they saw that the same reasoning applied. They then recalled that a funnel had been sighted near the tallest cloud being mapped. Waterspouts were also reported on Day 186. Studies of these waterspouts yielded "interesting relationships between the low-level cloud and boundary layer and the production of waterspouts which we believe shed some light on a class of tornadoes." This information was later applied to a waterspout over Great Salt Lake where a similar waterspout occurred.

LeMone: "I think we documented at least 5 fair weather situations, and found that the buoyancy-flux profile had fairly universal behavior--decreasing almost linearly with height to a value of about 0.1 times the surface value at the top of the mixed layer. However, the temperature and humidity profiles had much more varied behavior. When it was nearly clear, the humidity flux decreased with height--evaporation at the surface was replenishing the moisture in the mixed layer faster than mixing in of dry air from above was drying the PBL out. But when there were cumulus clouds, the humidity flux increased with height--the cumulus clouds were taking more moisture out of the mixed layer than the surface evaporation could supply, and the boundary layer dried out."

However, I later asked Dr. LeMone whether this behavior of the humidity flux held true when the boundary layer was over land (as in CASES-97), rather than a body of water. "Actually, we had no cumulus clouds in CASES-97--not a one! (This was something totally unexpected--in fact, we were going to use cumulus clouds to calibrate our aircraft--we fly up to cloud base to see if the temperature and dew point temperatures are equal)."

Yanai: "During these years [the early 1970's] meteorologists became keenly aware of the significance of organized cumulus convection as heat and moisture sources to the large-scale tropical motion systems. At the same time, cumulus convection is controlled by the large-scale processes. This 'cumulus-large-scale interaction- was considered a key question to be addressed by th GATE. So, I was very stimulated in my research that might provide a guide for observational and analysis strategy of GATE." Albrecht:
"It was the GATE experience that was a guiding force in many of the research activities I've been involved with over the last 25 years.  During my participation in projects like FIRE and ASTEX, I've always tried to ensure that students were heavily involved."


PERSONAL EXPERIENCES:

Simpson:

"There were 13 instrumented aircraft in GATE and I flew on all of them. I particularly enjoyed flying on the Soviet aircraft, where the scientists were making calculations on slide rules and greatly envied my HP 35. We never did get any data from the Soviet aircraft although we did from their ships."

"I was Mission Scientist of Day 261 which meant that I planned all the aircraft tracks in such a way that cloud mapping could be done by photogrammetry. A square pattern 80 km on a side was flown at a number of different levels. The key aircraft all had side-looking cameras on both sides. Using the time it took a cloud feature to cross the screen when projected the distance and height of each cloud feature could be obtained. We made a map of virtually every single cloud within and to some distance outside the square."

LeMone: "When GATE started, all discussions were translated into French and Russian--everything took three times as long. Thus, once we got going, the Russians would all sit together with quiet simultaneous translation, and the French just sat and listened (they all knew English). The Germans were fluent in English."

"I think the friction between the national groups was kept to a minimum. We socialized quite a bit, and Joach Kuettner kept the meetings collegial. The Mission Selection Team, headed by Joach, consisted of members from the major nations. I don't recall people feeling slighted, although there was friction when we were trying to coordinate flights or fly intercomparisons."

The scientists, being from all different countries, had varying reactions to President Nixon's resignation.


"The French I talked to didn't really know what the fuss was."

"Some of the Germans jokingly congratulated us on getting rid of our 'Hitler'."

"The Soviets took me out drinking one night and then when I didn't want to drink they took me out to dinner, before finally asking me--who is this Gerald ford? This particular group's interpretation was that the Americans got rid of Nixon because he had been to friendly with the Communists, and replaced him with a member of a well-known capitalist family (as in Ford cars)."

"I can't remember the British reaction, although I heard Nixon's resignation on BBC. Afterwards, the reporter said some rather derogatory things about Nixon that I thought weren't called for (why beat on a dead horse--the guy resigned) and then played O Danny Boy, which seemed far more appropriate for mourning a presidency that died."

Albrecht:
"Before I started my graduate studies at Colorado State University, I knew of GATE even though I didn't know it by that name.  In the spring of 1972 I was applying to graduate schools and had been accepted for admission and offered assistantships at both the University of Arizona and Colorado State University.  Just as I had made a decision to go to Arizona, I received a letter from Professor Stephen Cox at Colorado State describing an exotic field program in Africa scheduled for the summer of 1974.  I took the bait and made plans to attend CSU.  When I arrived that fall, Dr. Cox's first question to me was 'Do you have an aversion to flying?'  Although I was initially a bit puzzled by this question, I later learned why this question was so critical for my participation in GATE."

"During my first two years at CSU I was involved with the evaluation and development of radiation instrumentation for airborne applications in GATE while I worked on my M.S. thesis on the effects of differential radiative heating on the dynamics of tropical waves."

"we spent almost four months flying as observers in aircraft carrying radiometers to support Professor Cox's project to develop radiative budgets for the GATE study area....  During each intensive phase of GATE, the students working with Dr. Cox were on a schedule of two days of flying followed by a day off.  Since the aircraft flights were as long as 10-12 hours on the DC-6, we not only got an excellent first-hand look at tropical weather, but also lots of flying time.  Although the excitement of being in a foreign country and spending hours flying over the tropical eastern Atlantic was a remarkable experience in its own right, our daily interactions with scientists from all over the world was a unique aspect of the GATE experience."



HOW HAS GATE BEEN USEFUL IN THE REST OF YOUR CAREER?

Simpson:

A postdoc, W.-K Tao, joined the Goddard Space Flight Center in 1983 and brought with him a cloud ensemble model. "We could now model groups of clouds and immediately applied the model to a GATE squall line. The model has been improved in many ways, by adding radiation, by better microphysics, by more realistic boundary layers and other mathematical improvements."

"The GATE squall line has become a classical test of all cloud models of tropical clouds. Since Tao's model is used for a majority of the algorithms for the TRMM satellite, the GATE data are contributing in this way to an ongoing space mission in 1998."

LeMone: In planning CASES-97, Dr. LeMone used what she learned in GATE to make sure the project ran smoothly. "In planning it, we realized the importance of blending different datasets. In GATE, we had numerous ships about launching sondes; or with tethered balloons. The combination of this instrumentation provided more information than one set of instruments could alone.... We also learned how useful it was to have a defined synoptic field." Therefore, CASES-97 used a variety of instruments and was strategically located. "CASES-97 combined aircraft (2) with serial radiosonde ascents (each 90 minutes over a 24-hour cycle), surface data (up to 12 stations providing flux and met data), the S-Pol radar (to provide rainfall distributions when it did rain, to provide PBL height, eddy structure, and winds during fair-weather IOPs). And we located CASES-97 in a data-rich region--it is in the Walnut River basin, east of Wichita, Kansas, in southeast Kansas. This lies within the ARM-CART region, is in the NE triangle of the NOAA profiler hexagon, and lies within the region for which data are being archived for GCIP (in fact, the CASES data will form part of the GCIP data archive). Also, Argonne has sited its Argonne Boundary Layer Experiments instrumentation here--providing continuous data from wind and virtual-temperature profiling systems as well as one of the surface-flux stations." Yanai: "We still use the data from GATE because it is of high quality. But we also use data from more recent experiments including TOGA COARE." Albrecht:
"GATE provided me with an appreciation of the role of observations as a reality check for my modeling work."


CONCLUSIONS:
In my research of some of the scientists involved in GATE, I have found that GATE served as a major part of their careers.  Working with scientists from around the world did cause difficulties in some instances, but the leaders of the project managed to keep any hostilities to a minimum and the environment one in which all could learn and thrive.  I find it quite amazing that each of the four scientists that I talked to have been involved in very different projects since GATE, but their experiences 25 years ago have helped them all in various ways.  I would like to thank Dr. Simpson, Dr. LeMone, Dr. Yanai, and Dr. Albrecht  for taking the time to answer my questions and help me with this in-depth look at how GATE affected the lives and careers of those individuals who were a part of it. Without their help, none of this would have been possible.
 

Last revised:10 September, 1998 by Anneliese Sherer; 23 July, 1999 by AMS